Skip to content
B — partly documented

The Bacanal del Gnoco

the Veneto · The Po plain and the northern Apennines
Verona, the San Zeno quarter; today's procession crosses the city and does not coincide with the historic area

The Bacanal del Gnoco — the festival everyone dates to 1531 and a physician's will: the will exists and the bequest does not, and the first certain notice is an expense of 1574 paid with the Podestà's fines.

An accounting office: two clerks at a high desk, one writing in a large register with a quill, the other stacking counted coins on the wood. On the wall, a worn relief with a winged lion; on a bench, in shadow, a man waits with his cap in his hand. The only light is a candle.
Variants and dialect names
today Bacanàl del Gnòco, and the day is called vènare gnocolàr. But the oldest form attested in the documents is another: venere casolàro, the Friday of the casolìn, of cheese. In the acts the feast appears as the gnocchi feast of the venere casolàro
What is told
The Verona carnival, in the San Zeno quarter, on the last Friday of carnival. The version one reads everywhere begins with «A.D. 1531»: a famine, a bakers' strike, and the physician Tomaso da Vico leaving money by will to distribute flour, bread, wine, butter and cheese at San Zeno.

An article of 2022 went and checked, and found this:

— the only surviving will of Tomaso da Vico, of 13 May 1531, contains no such bequest. The universal heir is his son Marc'Antonio, and there are no charitable legacies. What is documented of Da Vico is instead a contribution of 25 ducats to a city loan of 1526 for buying grain: a different thing, and five years earlier;
— of the bakers' strike there is no documentary trace. Documented instead are the floods of the Adige and the Council's measures against beggars, in April 1530;
— the first certain notice of the feast is an expense of 16 April 1574: the Podestà orders his gastaldo to be reimbursed 120 and a half lire spent on the feast, and the money comes from fines imposed on three named men.
What it was forthe author’s reading
So it is not private charity: it is a public expense paid with the Venetian Podestà's fines, and that mechanism is documented from 1574 and holds at least until 1643. A popular festival funded by penalties, with the names of the three fined men written into the record: it is the kind of detail a legend cannot invent.

Nor is it an unbroken tradition. An Informazione of 1600 says the custom was resumed in 1592 after an interruption of fifteen years or more; the expenses resume in 1595. The first mention of the stage is of 1577. And the first reference to the day is earlier but says nothing of gnocchi: in 1509-1510 the friars of Santa Maria della Scala buy cheese and butter for the venere casolàro.

The best question remains: where, then, does the story of 1531 come from? It has authors and dates. The Relazione of Alessandro Carli of 18 January 1802, reprinted in the booklet of Alessandro Torri of 1847; Torri's own booklets, of 1818 and 1847; and the alternative proposal of Da Persico, 1820, which backdates the origin to a famine of 1406. The «story of 1531» circulates today because it is the nineteenth-century received version, not because any act says it.
Where it is attested
Claudio Bismara, «Il carnevale a Verona e nel suo territorio tra XV e XVI secolo: una storia documentata», in Studi Veronesi, VII, ed. Andrea Brugnoli and Pierpaolo Brugnoli, Verona 2022, the volume's opening article, p. 7 according to the index, text at pp. 8-28, appendix pp. 29-31. Open access on the journal's site. Read in part and by interrogation, in three passes: from it come the will of 13 May 1531 and the 25 ducats of 1526 (note 6), the expense of 16 April 1574 and the three fined men (note 72), the 1509-1510 of the friars (note 12, on Fainelli 1922), and the dates 1577, 1592, 1595-1600, 1643.

Guida generale degli Archivi di Stato italiani, entry Archivio di Stato di Verona, read in part on the two entries needed: Rettori veneti, p. 1254 (1419-1807; finding aid indicated: the 1882 inventory) and Ufficio del registro, p. 1252, with the series Testamenti città e territorio, 1408-1752, 387 bundles. Caveat: the Guida's OCR is corrupt on the quantity figures, which must be rechecked on paper.

Used as a source of the error and not of the fact: the proceedings of the conference Giù la maschera! I Carnevali tradizionali delle Tre Venezie, Verona, 17-18 September 2021, hosted by the University of Verona, which repeats the origin as «documented» in 1531 and speaks of 491 years.

Not opened, and they are the real documents: the paper recording the 1574 expense; the will of 13 May 1531, for which note 6 gives no bundle or folio; the Informazione of 1600 and the acts of 1592 and 1595. Also never opened: A. Torri, Cenni storici…, Verona 1847, pp. 5-10 (where Carli's Relazione is reprinted), V. Fainelli, «Il baccanale del gnocco a Verona», La Lettura XXII (1922), 3, pp. 211-214, and G. B. Da Persico, Descrizione di Verona e della sua provincia, Verona 1820, p. 255 n. 48.
Caution
No quotation is printed. The readings passed through a tool that summarises and truncates: the facts are attributed with the note, the words are not. The only form given as exact is the old name of the day, venere casolàro, which is a term and not a sentence.

The shelfmark is second-hand, and there is a discrepancy. The 1574 expense is, according to note 72 of the article, in ASVr, Rettori veneti, b. 105, c. 1140v. That shelfmark was not checked against the inventory of the fonds — which dates from 1882 and is not online — and there is a detail that invites caution: the Guida generale describes the Rettori veneti in mazzi, not in buste. Whoever uses it should verify it first.

1574 is not a safe threshold. One reading of the same article reports that from 1568 the displays of the Filotima cavalry were moved to the Friday to escort the Rettori to the gnocchi feast (p. 21). If that 1568 is right, the threshold date is not 1574. Here 16 April 1574 is given as the first notice of the expense, and the discrepancy is flagged.

Other discrepancies, reported and not smoothed over. The article's title differs between the running head and the index of the same volume. The final page: one reading gives 7-33, the other 7-34. The duty on chestnuts and olives, with which the Republic is said to have funded the feast, is attributed by one reading to a source of 1640 and by the other generically to «later sources»: the date 1640 is not written. And for Fainelli the bibliography gives pp. 211-214 while note 12 cites p. 202: one of the two is wrong.

The Papà del Gnòco does not appear. The character who is today the centre of the rite has no attestation at all in the open source: nothing on his antiquity, nothing on how long he has been elected, nothing on any link with 1531.

No pagan or pre-Christian origin. No open academic source asserts one for this festival. The two backdating hypotheses in play — the 1406 famine and a Venetian reward for San Zeno's loyalty — are declared by their own authors to lack documentary support.

The figures for today's event are partisan. «More than a hundred groups», «about five kilometres», «some thirty groups»: all from the 2021 conference volume, and contradicting one another within the same text. They are the statements of those who organise, not data.

Unknown: how much of today's apparatus — float, parade, groups, menu — is a nineteenth- or twentieth-century invention. All that can be said is that the narrative of the origin is nineteenth-century, and that it has authors and dates.

The grade says how well the entry is documented, not how interesting it is. How the grades are assigned.

In the same area

Related by theme

Entries that share the motif, the phenomenon behind it or the history of their collection — not the geography.

← Back to the atlas of Italy